New York City hires H-1Bs and outsources the rest to India

Date: Tuesday, June 30, 2009 5:04 AM

<<<<< JOB DESTRUCTION NEWSLETTER No. 2033 -- 6/30/2009 >>>>>

New York City hired IBM for a large contract. IBM in turn outsourced parts of
the work to Mumbai, India and for the work that had to be done in the city,
they imported about 17 Indian H-1Bs.

A city spokesman defended the choice to use IBM for the contract because, as
he said, their computer systems are so old it would be impossible to find
Americans that know how to work on them. Surprisingly a 25 year old Indian H-
1B from Mumbai named Sunny Amin knew how to work on these legacy systems well
enough to get an H-1B visa. He got his education in India which either says
something about how outdated those schools are, or how cheap H-1Bs are to hire
in the U.S., or both!

The work involves maintaining the city's databases which hold property and
other tax records. Those databases hold a wealth of information that would be
useful for crime, espionage, and terrorism and yet New York seems unconcerned
with the privacy and national security issues involved with using foreign
nationals to do the work.

That excellent and revealing article was on the New York Post. The web page
has a comments section that is worth reading and posting to.

Meanwhile, the New York Times was busy planting spin by publishing a
commentary by Mr. Flat Earth himself (Thomas Friedman). He explains why we
need more H-1Bs. He rather callously states that we should buy people as
though they are commodities.

Now is when we should be stapling a green card to the diploma of any
foreign student who earns an advanced degree at any U.S. university,
and we should be ending all H-1B visa restrictions on knowledge
workers who want to come here. They would invent many more jobs than
they would supplant. The world s best brains are on sale. Let s buy
more!

Just my opinion, but I don't believe these two articles are a coincidence.
Somehow the NYT found out about the Post article just in time to plant some H-
1B propaganda.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

http://www.nypost.com/seven/06282009/news/regionalnews/nyc_hit_by_nerd_job_rob_176570.htm

NYC HIT BY NERD JOB ROB

By SUSAN EDELMAN

June 28, 2009 --

It's a geek tragedy.

While the city vows to save and create jobs for recession-ravaged New Yorkers,
one of its biggest contractors is importing techies from India, instead of
hiring local computer nerds.

IBM won a $1.9 million contract with the Department of Finance to analyze its
old main databases so they can be improved, but the company has transported
"consultants" from Mumbai and other parts of India to do most of the work.

At least 17 employees hired by an IBM subsidiary in India have worked in New
York since October, inspecting the city's computer systems, which hold
property and other tax records, insiders said.

"It was a dream come true," said Sunny Amin, 25, who traveled from his Mumbai
home to the Big Apple -- his first US visit.

Amin, who has an engineering degree from a college in Aurangabad, landed his
first job with IBM-India.

While a bit lost at first, Amin said, he rented an apartment in Parsippany,
NJ, and commuted by bus. After nine months on Wall Street, he's being sent to
another IBM job, in Minneapolis, on his three-year work visa.

Amin would not reveal his pay but did say, "I make about 10 times more than I
would in India."

In contract documents, IBM says it pays its technical consultants at rates
ranging from $26.24 to $278 an hour, not counting travel and living expenses.

It could not be learned whether IBM pays its Mumbai recruits the same rates,
though watchdogs say US firms hire thousands of workers from India because
they come cheap. IBM did not return calls.

But Amin's fortune means US citizens get shut out of well-paying jobs, critics
charge.

"It's like a slap in the face," said Robert Ajaye, president of Local 2627, a
union of city-employed computer specialists. "We have people in house who
could do this job."

Instead, he said, some city staffers have had to "translate" for Indian
techies lacking English skills.

Finance spokesman Sam Miller defended the contract.

"Our systems are so old that there are not many companies that have the
ability to work on them. IBM does," he said.

susan.edelman@nypost.com

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/28/opinion/28friedman.html

June 28, 2009
Op-Ed Columnist
Invent, Invent, Invent
By THOMAS L. FRIEDMAN

I was at a conference in St. Petersburg, Russia, a few weeks ago and
interviewed Craig Barrett, the former chairman of Intel, about how America
should get out of its current economic crisis. His first proposal was this:
Any American kid who wants to get a driver s license has to finish high
school. No diploma -- no license. Hey, why would we want to put a kid who can
barely add, read or write behind the wheel of a car?

Now what does that have to do with pulling us out of the Great Recession? A
lot. Historically, recessions have been a time when new companies, like
Microsoft, get born, and good companies separate themselves from their
competition. It makes sense. When times are tight, people look for new, less
expensive ways to do old things. Necessity breeds invention.

Therefore, the country that uses this crisis to make its population smarter
and more innovative -- and endows its people with more tools and basic
research to invent new goods and services -- is the one that will not just
survive but thrive down the road.

We might be able to stimulate our way back to stability, but we can only
invent our way back to prosperity. We need everyone at every level to get
smarter.

I still believe that America, with its unrivaled freedoms, venture capital
industry, research universities and openness to new immigrants has the best
assets to be taking advantage of this moment -- to out-innovate our
competition. But we should be pressing these advantages to the max right now.

Russia, it seems to me, is clearly wasting this crisis. Oil prices rebounded
from $30 to $70 a barrel too quickly, so the pressure for Russia to really
reform and diversify its economy is off. The struggle for Russia s post-
Communist economic soul -- whether it is going to be more OPEC than O.E.C.D.,
a country that derives more of its wealth from drilling its mines than from
tapping its minds -- seems to be over for now.

At the St. Petersburg exposition center, showing off the Russian economy, the
two biggest display booths belonged to Gazprom, the state-controlled oil and
gas company, and Sberbank, Russia s largest state-owned bank.
Russian companies that actually made things that the world wanted were
virtually nonexistent: Two-thirds of Russia s exports today are oil and gas.
Gazprom makes the money, and Sberbank lends it out.

As one Western banker put it, when oil is $35 a barrel, Russia "has no choice"
but to reform, to diversify its economy and to put in place the rule of law
and incentives that would really stimulate small business. But at $70 a
barrel, it takes an act of enormous "political will," which the petro-old
K.G.B. alliance that dominates the Kremlin today is unlikely to summon. Too
much rule of law and transparency would constrict the ruling clique s own
freedom of maneuver.

China is also courting trouble. Recently -- in the name of censoring
pornography -- China blocked access to Google and demanded that computers sold
in China come supplied with an Internet nanny filter called Green Dam Youth
Escort, starting July 1. Green Dam can also be used to block politics, not
just Playboy. Once you start censoring the Web, you restrict the ability to
imagine and innovate. You are telling young Chinese that if they really want
to explore, they need to go abroad.

We should be taking advantage. Now is when we should be stapling a green card
to the diploma of any foreign student who earns an advanced degree at any U.S.
university, and we should be ending all H-1B visa restrictions on knowledge
workers who want to come here. They would invent many more jobs than they
would supplant. The world s best brains are on sale. Let s buy more!

Barrett argues that we should also use this crisis to: 1) require every state
to benchmark their education standards against the best in the world, not the
state next door; 2) double the budgets for basic scientific research at the
National Science Foundation, the Department of Energy and the National
Institute of Standards and Technology; 3) lower the corporate tax rate; 4)
revamp Sarbanes-Oxley so that it is easier to start a small business; 5) find
a cost-effective way to extend health care to every American.

We need to do all we can now to get more brains connected to more capital to
spawn more new companies faster. As Jeff Immelt, the chief of General
Electric, put it in a speech on Friday, this moment is "an opportunity to turn
financial adversity into national advantage, to launch innovations of lasting
value to our country."

Sometimes, I worry, though, that what oil money is to Russia, our ability to
print money is to America. Look at the billions we just printed to bail out
two dinosaurs: General Motors and Chrysler.

Lately, there has been way too much talk about minting dollars and too little
about minting our next Thomas Edison, Bob Noyce, Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, Vint
Cerf, Jerry Yang, Marc Andreessen, Sergey Brin, Bill Joy and Larry Page.
Adding to that list is the only stimulus that matters.
Otherwise, we re just Russia with a printing press.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Newsletter Homepage:
http://www.JobDestruction.com/shameh1b/JobDestructionNews.htm

Support this Newsletter and www.JobDestruction.com by donating:
www.zazona.com/Donations.htm

To Be removed from this mailing list, reply to this email with UNSUbSCRIBE in
the subject window

Back to archives